I want to study philosophy on my own

Navid asked:

So, I am attempting learn philosophy on my own. To be specific, I want to know what you can tell me about learning to understand philosophical thinking and philosophical texts. How do I learn the language and the process of analyzing philosophical arguments and also crafting such arguments?

Answer by Gideon Smith-Jones

I guess, Navid, the question I’d ask you is, Why? Why learn philosophy on your own? what are you afraid of? being confused by the opinions of others? being made to look foolish? There will always be cleverer students than you, and a lot more who are less clever.

Sure, you can learn a lot by yourself, reading classic philosophical texts and trying to grapple with them. That would be one way. (You can start by looking at Section 3 of the Pathways Introductory Book List.)

But how can you tell whether you’re making headway, when you only have yourself to judge your progress? You may think you’ve ‘cracked’ Hume, say, or Plato, but maybe you were just making up your own idiosyncratic interpretation as you went along.

Yet some do it – successfully. Read the classic text first, then test your initial interpretation against the editor’s or translator’s Introduction, or modern secondary texts. (A big error students make is reading the secondary material first, so they never get to first base learning how to grapple with a text because it’s all laid out for them.)

Maybe, when you’ve been doing this for a while, you will begin to feel a strong urge to discuss your ideas with others. There are lots of philosophy forums out there. I’m not saying it’s an easy task deciding which ones are worth joining. You have to use your best judgement. But you were doing that anyway, deciding what to read, forming a view of what you’ve read. Discovering who is your ‘favourite philosopher’ maybe.

There’s a term you may have heard before, ‘autodidact’. It means that you taught (didact) yourself (auto). It can be done. Forums can help. The biggest stumbling block, however, is writing. Who is going to read what you write? Other autodidacts? That’s one of the main reasons why one takes a university or college course – to have the opportunity to have your work assessed by persons qualified to judge.

Something I haven’t mentioned: you will discover that there is no single agreed standard for the ‘language and process of analyzing philosophical arguments’. It all depends whether you study, say, at the University of London, or the University of the Sorbonne – or the University of Tehran.

Maybe, after you’ve done a bit of reading, you will have a better idea of how you want to take things to the next stage. You could do worse than join our own school, Pathways to Philosophy.

4 thoughts on “I want to study philosophy on my own

  1. What a condescending, arrogant perspective on education. How shameful! As someone in graduate school, I obviously think formal education is helpful. However, this kind of attitude and assumption-making turns people away from all kinds of education. Is this author really so uncreative that they can’t conceive of any other reason to pursuit education outside of formal universities? The education field is filled with far too many that appeal to the authority of a degree instead of recognizing education for all that it can and should be. There are a variety of reasons one may pursuit education outside of a university: personal improvement; a better understanding of concepts that shape the sociological world (religion, politics, etc.), or individual struggles and focuses; financial barriers; time constraints; personal abilities and previous knowledge that is better served through other educational goals than general public and much more. Anyone that believes the only acceptable form of learning is through a university isn’t intelligent or creative enough to think for themselves. How dare you try to inhibit or discourage learning in others.

  2. For a “philosopher” you jumped to quite many assumptions with questions. All was said was to study philosophy on your own.. Nothing about what you said, then again i just started learning!

  3. Gideon, because for some people affording a formal education in philosophy is prohibitive. Next time, start with helpful information and advice rather than talking down to someone with a genuine inquiry.

  4. Ya I guess I wanted to do it on my own because I want to know how to think rather than be told what to think. But as you said, one may just become too idiosyncratic alone but then again idiosyncratic may not be bad of its true. Many new ideas are idiosyncratic to some extent until they become mainstream. I guess I just want to be able to think independently since we live in a world now where the business of truth is especially dicey. We’re inundated by all kinds of data and information but few are equipped to actually make real inferences or conclusions about the data. It’s just this swirling mess that no one knows how to deal with. I don’t wanna be one of those people who can’t deal with it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.